Sitecore 8 vs 9: An Absolute Digital Experience Showdown

Sitecore 8 vs 9: These digital experience heavyweights each pack powerful features for crafting customer journeys.

But which version should you use to deliver engaging experiences across channels?

Let's dive into this long-running software matchup to compare capabilities and determine the right fit for your needs. Game on!

Round 1: Deployment and Infrastructure

Out of the gate, Sitecore 9 strides ahead with cloud-native deployment options. Sitecore 9.1 debuted the Experience Cloud, enabling full platform hosting on Azure PaaS. This cloud capability expands deployment flexibility beyond on-prem and hybrid models.

Sitecore 8, as an on-prem solution, requires more hands-on infrastructure like configuring MongoDB for xDB. Sitecore 9 simplifies things, consolidating xDB and xConnect functionality into SQL Server. This streamlines the data tier to a single database platform.

Round one goes to Sitecore 9 for opening up cloud deployment and easing infrastructure demands.

Round 2: Scalability and Performance

Both versions incorporate a scalable architecture, but Sitecore 9 pulls ahead with enhancements like the Sitecore Host framework. Decoupled microservices and containerization options allow for nimble scaling of deployment components.

Sitecore 9 also improves performance through optimized session state management and reference data services. The introduction of blob storage further boosts speed by storing media assets on Azure rather than in the database.

Sitecore 8 lacks these scalability hooks and performance upgrades. Round two is a knock-out for Sitecore 9.

Round 3: Security

Security is paramount for any digital platform. Sitecore 9 again lands more punches, integrating native GDPR compliance tools plus the Identity Server for access control. Federated authentication enables SSO flexibility across apps.

While Sitecore 8 provides a robust security foundation, it misses out on identity and access advancements. Sitecore 9 dominates with both compliance and authentication capabilities.

Round 4: Omnichannel Content Delivery

Here's where Sitecore 9 unveils a real game-changer. The addition of Sitecore JavaScript Services (JSS) unlocks headless CMS potential for distributing content across any channel or device.

Sitecore 8 focused primarily on traditional web content management. But Sitecore 9's JSS framework future-proofs omnichannel delivery, from IoT to VR and beyond.

QEdge’s LinkedIn Page

Round 5: Customer Intelligence

Harnessing customer data for personalization gives any brand a competitive advantage. Sitecore 9 unveils its AI-powered assistant, Cortex, to uncover insights and patterns from customer interactions.

Sitecore 8 also enables data-driven personalization, just without the machine learning IQ of Cortex. For leveraging intelligence across the experience, Sitecore 9 and Cortex are the undisputed champs.

Round 6: Commerce Capabilities

For brands selling online, integrated commerce is a must-have. Sitecore 9 introduces the headless Experience Commerce engine for developer-friendly e-commerce.

Sitecore 8 offered commerce via the Commerce Connect framework but required a Commerce Server for backend functions. Sitecore 9 Commerce unshackles the commerce engine for flexible implementation.

Round 7: Marketing Automation

Today's martech landscape demands robust automation to engage customers across channels. Sitecore 9 includes built-in journey orchestration and campaign tools like exclusion lists, A/B testing, and more.

While Sitecore 8 supports basic marketing automation functions, Sitecore 9 does more out-of-the-box without the need for add-ons. It offers fully-fledged automation for the digital marketer's playbook.

And the Winner Is...

After seven hard-fought rounds, Sitecore 9 emerges victorious by leveraging cloud, headless, automation, and intelligence advancements.

But for brands running smoothly on Sitecore 8, is migrating to Version 9 necessary?

The case for upgrading to Sitecore 9

For many Sitecore 8 users, migrating to Version 9 may not be urgent. But the improvements are substantial:

• Cloud and headless capabilities to future-proof digital experiences
• Performance, scalability, and security enhancements
• Deeper personalization and customer intelligence
• Built-in automation and commerce engines

The migration path from Sitecore 8 to 9 has also been streamlined. An incremental upgrade is possible, even bypassing interim versions as desired. This reduces the effort, risk, and resources required to upgrade.

Brands looking to push digital innovation and retain platform flexibility will find Sitecore 9's features transformative. But upgrading should align with business goals, not solely for the sake of "latest and greatest” tech.

Key considerations before migrating to Sitecore 9:

• Evaluate if new capabilities will address brand needs and opportunities
• Audit platform status and technical debt to identify upgrade risks
• Develop a business case outlining ROI, costs, and timelines
• Assess required code and architecture changes for migration
• Allocate resources for testing, training, and launch

For brands seeking to unlock new digital capabilities and platform longevity, Sitecore 9 warrants strong consideration. But approach migration as delivering business impact, not just chasing technology.

Sitecore 8 vs 9 - the road ahead

The digital landscape continues advancing rapidly. How will Sitecore evolve along with it?

Sitecore 10 focuses on simplifying integrations. It debuted a unified JSON framework for headless apps, plus revamped the Forms module and marketing tools.

The future roadmap also highlights smarter personalization through AI, expanded automation, and enhanced developer velocity. Sitecore will continue modernizing in step with digital disruption.

Which version makes the most sense for your brand? That requires analyzing business and customer needs against platform capabilities, both now and down the road.